Do Long-Term Rentals Or Short-Term Rentals Provide Better Investment Returns?

Do Long-Term Rentals Or Short-Term Rentals Provide Better Investment Returns?

Rental properties are a great investment strategy that can provide a low-risk return on your investment. While long-term rentals have traditionally been the model for investment properties, short-term rentals have become much more viable with the advent of sites like VRBO and Airbnb. That begs the question – which rental strategy will provide you with the best returns? Let’s take a look at both the advantages and the disadvantages of each model.

Long-Term Rentals: Advantages

Long-term rentals are those that are leased on a monthly or yearly basis. Some advantages of long-term rentals include:

  • Stability – Long-term rentals will provide property investors with a steady income stream, with many tenants staying for years if the property is properly managed.
  • Low turnover – Long-term tenants means less money spent marketing and looking for new renters, and less time that the property is vacant.
  • High demand – Renters will always be looking for long-term housing, especially in markets where the cost of homes is high.
  • Fewer legal issues – Traditional long-term rentals face fewer legal issues than those that short-term rentals are experiencing.
  • No utilities or furnishings – In most cases, tenants will absorb the costs for utilities and furnishings. 

Long-Term Rentals: Disadvantages

On the flipside, long-term rentals do have their share of disadvantages when compared to short-term rentals, such as:

  • Bad tenants – If you find yourself with bad tenants, then it can be complicated and expensive to evict them from your property.
  • Caps on rent increases – In many locations, municipalities will impose caps on how much rent can increase every year, making it difficult to compensate for inflation.
  • Restricted access – When you have long-term renters, your ability to check on the home will be limited, as you’ll need to give renters advance notice in order to inspect or repair the property.

Short-Term Rentals: Advantages

More and more real estate investors are turning to short-term rentals because of their advantages, which include:

  • More income potential – In many cases, short-term rentals are more lucrative than long-term rentals, because your nightly fees are higher and you can charge a premium during the high season.
  • Strong demandMore and more vacationers are turning to short-term rentals instead of traditional hotels.
  • Passive investment – Many real estate investors are finding that their short-term rentals provide a great opportunity for passive investment when property management companies are utilized for day-to-day operations.
  • Flexibility – If your short-term rental is in a desirable location, you can block off dates so that you can enjoy your own property.
  • Possible tax breaks – Depending on how many days a year you rent out your vacation property, you may be eligible for tax breaks on a second home.

Short-Term Rentals: Disadvantages

Although short-term rentals can seem like a homerun, they do have drawbacks. These include:

  • Legal issues – As mentioned above, some cities are placing restrictions on short-term rentals that may result in legal issues for the property owner.
  • High turnover – In short-term rentals, you may have guests who stay as little as one night, making maintenance a much bigger issue. You can help mitigate this problem by hiring an effective property management company.
  • Slow periods – If rentals in your area experience seasonal shifts, then you may find your vacancy rate to be much higher in the off-season.


Ultimately, only you can determine which rental strategy is right for you based on your needs. If stability is important to you, then a long-term rental may be more appropriate. If you are attracted to the benefits of a short-term rental but aren’t sure if it’s a good fit, you can always try it for a few months to see how it goes.

Contact Agent Property Management Today

Are you ready to place the management of your luxury property into expert hands? Then contact Agent Property Management today at 949-518-1899. Our team has decades of experience and is ready to assist you with all your property management needs.

Get a Free Estimate